Showing posts with label tim johnson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tim johnson. Show all posts

Friday, August 21, 2009

Misinformation

Today in the mail I got the gift of blog-fodder from Senator Tim Johnson. It was under the guise of clearing up all the misinformation regarding health care reform. So I'd like to offer some quotes from the addendum to his previous party-line release on health care reform along with a few comments about what's wrong with this picture.

In response to the question about why we should want reform when we already have the best care in the world Johnson says we do indeed have the best health care in the world "if you can afford it." He refers to an increasingly large number of people discover they are under-insured and makes the case this is a reason for reform.

Okay. I agree that the current course we are on in the financial side of health care is unsustainable. But is this a problem the governments needs to solve? In a free market health insurance providers will have to compete for the dollars of the average American. If the average American can't afford their rates, guess who doesn't get paid? That's right, the health insurance provider doesn't make much when nobody buys their insurance. That's what a competitive and free market is all about. So what's going to happen if we toss the government into this mix? Well, the government has no reason to keep costs down since they don't have to worry about competing or making money. So, eventually, the price goes up. Unfortunately that gets paid by raising taxes. So maybe it starts out reasonable but where will it be in ten years? Besides, if a person is under-insured, how is that the government's problem? It's my responsibility to make sure I have insurance I need.

On to the second issue in the letter. "I like the coverage I have now. How will I benefit from health care reform?" Johnson's response to this is a rich one. Here's his response: "Reform efforts will build upon the strengths of our health care system while fixing the parts that prevent so many from accessing affordable, quality health care. Health care reform will ensure that you and your family will have the secure and meaningful health care coverage you deserve."

Where do I begin? This is a sales pitch. What is health care reform? Why it's whatever you want it to be! Is a senator speaking or Willy Wonka? Raise your hand if you really believe this. Unfortunately, even if it was true, we still have a whole new set of problems sure to arise from the solution.

Third: "What is the difference between a public insurance option and a government takeover of health care?" Good question. Johnson's response: "A public option would simply be a government insurance plan that people could choose if they liked it better than the private insurance plans available to them. . . . This public option would exist side-by-side with the health insurance plans offered by a private plan that best suits their needs."

Right. Of course that's only until the government plan runs the private companies out of business and forces a more complete government takeover. This is the frustrating part about this debate on the democrat side of the aisle. I believe they know full well what this will do and that end-result is exactly what they want. They're just not man enough to admit it. Instead they desire a back-door approach. Force the crisis and then the country will cry out for us to take it over. Sounds like the housing crisis to me. An awful lot of that appears contrived as well. So maybe this tactic isn't so new. Don't worry, they'll blame it on the republicans when it happens anyway.

Fourth: "With our economy struggling, how can we afford health care reform?" Another real good question. His response: "Reform will undoubtedly be costly - but it is even more costly to do nothing." Oh, and I like this part: "In 30 years, one third of our nation's wealth will be spent on health care."

Wow. In 30 years? How can we solve this problem??? I know, let's commit one third of our wealth to it now! That way it won't be such a shock 30 years from now. After all, there's no possible way the free market system could possibly work well enough to fix this problem before then.

Well, all I can say is this: we can't solve a problem that comes in 30 years by the destruction of our nation today. If we commit these resources (unnecessarily) now, we may not have a nation to save in 30 years. And by saying "may" I think I'm being generous.

Fifth: "In an effort to cust costs, will the government begin rationing health care?" His response: "No, but we can cut costs by making smart choices about what works and avoiding unnecessary and ineffective treatments." Now that's a dim response. If you like that one, you're sure to enjoy this one: "The payments we make to providers have surprisingly little to do with patient outcomes. By paying better for good patient outcomes, we encourage providers to share test results with one another instead of repeating tests unnecessarily."

Where do I begin? Well, first of all, Johnson makes some good points in this section about how to reduce health care costs. But, really, does it take all that is on the table right now to accomplish these reductions? I don't think so. The Health Insurance industry could solve this issue tomorrow it was fully true. I've seen enough doctors who didn't share information and tests were repeated unnecessarily. Of course, if the patient stays on top of things, they can help the doctors get the information they need. At the same time, we might be leading to a situation where nobody tests because last month's tests didn't have the answer. Isn't it possible that multiple tests may be the doctor's idea of looking for something that didn't show up the first time but he believes is there? If we cut him off at the pass, isn't it the patient that suffers?

Rationing will happen with a government option. When the system becomes so bloated with bureaucrats and inefficiency that the government is forced to cut costs by denying care to the patient, rationing will have occurred. The problem is that the government is far far from the model of an efficient and incorruptible company. The current reality makes this all a pipe dream. Johnson, along with many of his cohorts, seems to honestly believe that if they say it won't happen, then surely it won't. I wish I could believe that but I've never seen anything to make me think it's even possible with our government.

Finally: "Medicare offers stable, affordable coverage to millions of Americans 65 and over. How will reform affect this program?" His response: "Health reform efforts will strengthen Medicare" by "reining in spiraling health costs that threaten teh long-term stability of the program." He believes all this "preventative care" due to better coverage will result in better care in our old age and less stress on Medicare costs.

Well, if you believe the rest, then that is marginably possible. The real issue comes from his next statement, however. He says, "Recently, outrageous accusations have claimed that health reform will 'kill seniors' and that panels will decide who is healthy enough to merit care. There is no truth to these claims. Unfortunately, scare tactics such as these only mislead the public and prevent a constructive discussion of the issues."

This is the democrat way of getting rid of those who oppose them. They claim we're all using nothing more than scare tactics, as if there is no validity to this. As if there isn't even the remotest possibility that some form of this could happen. The idea of "death panels" is really just an issue of cause and effect. The near-certainty of rationing necessarily leads to someone, somewhere, sometime making the decision of who gets care and who doesn't. This is where the real crazy thoughts happen. Who is the most expendable? Who is the least important?

There is another possibility in all this. We could wind up with a universal system based on how well the government has handled health care on Indian Reservations. We see plenty of this in South Dakota and Tim Johnson should know that. He's been honored enough on the reservations. "Don't get sick after June." Why? Because all the money available for health care has already been spent by then. Don't expect adequate care after June. Check out the following link at YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GzihyQz0ovE .

I don't want that. I don't want the government meddling in health care. I can handle some regulation but leave the real reform to the American people. We will handle the insurance companies. It is our dollars that keep the around and it a lack of our dollars that push them to change.

Friday, August 7, 2009

My Representatives

I've been pleased to find that it's easy for me to tell my representatives how I feel about things. I just go to http://www.senate.gov/ and http://www.house.gov/ and look up my representatives by state. I can then send out an email expressing my opinion.

Then I wait for responses. I desire responses that are thoughtful and show me that my representative actually has an opinion on the subject. They may disagree with me but I want to know they've thought about it and that they want to hear my voice.

I am in South Dakota and I've recently sent messages to my representatives about the confirmation of Judge Sotomayor (I'm still opposed) and about healthcare reform. So here are my results:

John Thune: I voted for you and you keep voting the way I would vote. Obviously I like that. You opposed the confirmation of Sotomayor and you have provided well-thought responses to my emails. Thank you Senator Thune for listening and for caring enough about what you do to have your own opinion and to value mine.

Tim Johnson: I didn't vote for you and never will. I have unpopular opinions regarding your health and fitness for congressional duty. I recently received a well-written letter from you regarding your position on health are reform. An email would have been better (and cheaper) but I appreciate the response. In your letter you said, "We have a moral obligation to fix the problems that plague health care in America . . . ." I disagree with that. Healthcare is a privilege, not a right. Perhaps we've believed healthcare is a right for too long to understand that concept anymore. So when I couldn't afford health insurance, I just went without. Those results are mine to live with and if it was important enough to me to make sure I had it, I'd find a way to get the resources to pay for it. By the way, I have health insurance and that insurance is cheaper today than it was 9 years ago. I accomplished that because I have a choice in who my insurance provider is and I took the time to find a plan that suits my needs. So, in my view, I am not dealing with the "skyrocketing cost of health insurance." Now, consider the current hospital system. Certainly the majority, if not all, Americans have access to a non-profit hospital. These hospitals typically do a fine job of finding a way for writing off medical expenses or finding alternative funding for those who need there services. The more the government becomes involved, the less the American people do. Donations will decrease and more of the burden will be placed upon the government. Costs will go up as well as problems with the system.

You wrote in your letter, "While the wealthiest Americans receive generous tax breaks, the number of average citizens who cannot obtain access to basic medical services and struggle to pay health insurance costs continues to grow." First of all, this is another way of saying, "Let's make the wealthy pay more to cover the costs of those less fortunate." That's redistribution of wealth and that's socialism. We are a democracy, for now. Second, that statement does not take into account that the wealthiest Americans are employing the less fortunate Americans and, in a great many cases, are offering health insurance to their employees in ways that already absorb much, if not all, of that cost.

You also wrote in your letter, "There has been a great deal of misinformation swelling around reform, lately, and I want to be clear in stating this is not a 'government takeover' of our health care system, nor a means of rationing care." First, President Obama has consistently talked about universal health care and most of the talk from the plans being put forward say this is just that, a government takeover of our health care system. You can say it isn't but I still call a spade a spade. Second, this reform may not see immediate rationing of care but it has an almost certain potential of reaching that state within a number of years. You have to consider what other politicians will do with this in the future as we open the door to ideas that offer a greater devaluing of life than we already have. Just listen to the ideas of Rom Emmanuel and see where his ideas are taking us.

Recent news reports say we now have a $1.3 Trillion deficit in the last 10 months. You mention in your letter that Obama has already created a $694 billion reserve fund for health care. Perhaps we would be better off applying that towards the deficit. I can't carry a deficit in my business and I don't think my government should be allowed to either.

Your letter was silent on the issue of abortion in the health care debate. The AP has confirmed that current health care reform options on the table absorb the cost of abortion. I am significantly displeased with the fact that my tax dollars already get sent to facilitate this terrible injustice all over the world. You've made your position on this issue very clear over the years and I sincerely pray for a change of heart in you that will help you to see this travesty for what it is. Regardless, I should never be forced to pay for that which I disagree with on such a passionate scale. In over 95% of abortion cases it is nothing more than an elective procedure. In that sense it is no different than a face-lift. In a moral sense, it is something far far worse. I DONT WANT TO PAY FOR SOMEONE ELSES KILLING OF AN INNOCENT CHILD!

All disagreements aside, I wish to state that I appreciate a much longer letter in response to this issue. Although it's well-written, it is still nothing more than the party line on this issue. I'd like to hear about where you may disagree with the president and your colleagues in Congress. Talk about what you see that we reall need to do to fix health care. Be inciteful and not just another outlet for the party voice. That voice represents very little, if any, of my own beliefs.

You also voted in favor of Sotomayor and your response to that issue was a short form letter that shows me you don't have an opinion of your own, rather just the party line. Please prove me wrong about that last statement. I want to know that you care about my voice and not just the party voice that shouts from somewhere other than South Dakota.

Stephanie Herseth: I didn't vote for you and I disagree with you often. But, your responses to me on these two issues show that you have thought about your position. I respect that. I was even pleasantly surprised to find we were not that far apart on Healthcare Reform. Thank you for having your own voice, even if I disagree. It is important to me that you are a Blue Dog Democrat. Our country cannot survive with the size of deficits are taking on. Soon no one will be willing to lend us the money we need because the amount we are borrowing is unpayable. I have hope that conservative values with regards to fiscal responsibility will keep health care reform from becoming exactly what the majority of Americans do not want - universal and government-run and controlled.